E-commerce · Semiotics · Cultural strategy

Discovering a Nation Within a Nation

Semiotics, sneakers and the new Indian consumer

Myntra · 2017 · Presented at ESOMAR 2017 and MRSI 2018

At a glance

  • Client: Myntra, India's largest online fashion retailer
  • Year: 2017
  • My role: Associate Vice President; qualitative research lead
  • Methods: Expert interviews, depth interviews, wardrobe audits, social listening, syndicated data, secondary research
  • Timeline: Research shared in early February; store launched on 10 March
  • Presented at: ESOMAR 2017 and MRSI 2018, co-presented with Myntra

Context

In 2017, Indian e-commerce was growing fast, and so were its losses. Myntra had turned gross-profit positive and was pushing towards EBITDA profitability, which meant moving away from deep discounting. The business needed categories that could sell at low or no discount.

Sneakers looked like one. Business analytics showed sneakers growing on the platform with no dedicated push, AI trend forecasting flagged them as an emerging fashion trend in India, and brand partners were ready to sign exclusive launches if Myntra could build a destination that worked without discounts.

The question

The brief was to build an exclusive in-app sneaker destination, and to do it in weeks. Research had to answer who this consumer really was, what needs drove them, how they shopped, what they made of Myntra, and what format the destination should take.

Underneath all of that sat a harder question: in a market trained to wait for a sale, what makes someone pay full price?

My role

I was Associate Vice President and led the qualitative research. I designed the research, ran the expert module myself (in-depth conversations with serious sneaker collectors), led the synthesis, and created the "Nation Within a Nation" construct and the consumer segments that Myntra went on to build around.

In 2017, finding these people was itself a research problem. Sneaker culture in India was still young.

Approach

We combined six streams of evidence so that no single source would carry the story:

  1. 01

    Expert interviews

    a Google Hangout with three serious collectors (an art director, a photographer-filmmaker and a blogger) to map the category from the inside and see where it was heading.

  2. 02

    Depth interviews

    10 one-on-one interviews with evolved, SEC A+ sneaker buyers aged 18 to 45, recruited from the client's TGI data, across Mumbai, Delhi, Bengaluru and Guwahati.

  3. 03

    Wardrobe audits

    looking at what people actually owned, not just what they said they bought.

  4. 04

    Social media listening

    to trace where awareness and aspiration came from.

  5. 05

    Syndicated data

    TGI, to size and profile the audience.

  6. 06

    Secondary research

    on the category, brands and global sneaker culture.

For data collection and analysis, I used Hofstede's cultural onion as the framework, moving from surface symbols and heroes through rituals down to underlying values. Because the deadline was so tight, findings were shared with the business as they emerged, not saved for a final report.

What we found

  1. 1

    Sneaker lovers behave like citizens of their own nation.

    Collectors from very different walks of life shared a common culture: shared values (risk-taking, discipline, prudence, a hunger for knowledge, a drive for perfection), shared rituals (active lifestyles, strict routines that still made room for the hobby), shared heroes (athletes and game-changing celebrities), and shared experience of life abroad. Their sense of belonging went beyond India's borders. This became the central construct: Sneaker Nation, a nation within a nation.

  2. 2

    India is many sneaker markets, not one.

    Average sneaker spend ranged from about ₹30,000 in Mumbai, where comfort, performance and athleisure led, to ₹10,000–15,000 in Delhi's flaunt-it, deal-seeking culture, about ₹15,000 in health-conscious, youthful Bengaluru, and about ₹3,500 in Guwahati, where early adopters wanted the latest style even at lower budgets.

  3. 3

    One category, four need states.

    Everyone wanted comfort, performance and style, but for different reasons: validation and standing out, belonging to a wider sport or pop-culture movement, influence within a subculture, and self-expression.

  4. 4

    Citizenship deepens over time.

    We mapped four segments along a journey of growing commitment:

  1. Fresh Off The Boat
  2. Ambivalent Settlers
  3. Green Card Holders
  4. Citizens
From newcomer to loyalist
  • Fresh Off The Boat: newcomers to the culture, buying cheaper fast-fashion sneakers and open to every brand as they work out what suits them.
  • Ambivalent Settlers: achievement-oriented, disciplined buyers who came to sneakers after earning their keep. Their reasons are rational (fitness, comfort, an easy way to add some fun to a conservative wardrobe), they ignore the culture's icons, and they would switch categories if something else offered the same benefits.
  • Green Card Holders: easy to dismiss as a Fresh Off The Boat on steroids, but deeply knowledgeable underneath, and working hard to become citizens of the sneaker world. They research obsessively, care for their pairs meticulously, settle into loyalty to one or two brands, and love to bring newcomers into the fold.
  • Citizens: the true sneakerheads and the gatekeepers of the culture. Highly quality-conscious and fiercely brand-loyal, they guard the culture against newcomers who don't appreciate what makes one sneaker different from another.

What we recommended

Build a club, not a store. These consumers wanted to belong, show off their collections and learn, as well as buy. The research recommended a community: the Myntra Sneaker Club, built on a profile-page wireframe where people could follow, interact, engage and buy. It was the first of its kind in India.
Premium, but not exclusive. The business had planned a purely premium destination. The research showed that even devoted buyers were value-seekers, and that a narrow range would undermine the one-stop-destination promise. We recommended variety across price points, designs and brands.
Target the collectors-in-the-making. We recommended focusing on Fresh Off The Boat and Ambivalent Settlers, the two segments actively building collections, so that Myntra could educate them and grow with them as they matured.

The insights also shaped the execution: a black-and-gold identity, new lifestyle photography for more than 150 styles, and sections such as New Arrivals, Trending Now, Sneak-peek and Iconic.

Impact

  • 10xrevenue growth in the category
  • 40%jump in conversion
  • 22%new customer acquisition
  • 1100%growth in list views

The launch campaign earned more than 2 million impressions on Twitter and Instagram, with a 25% click-through rate. Brand partners rated the Myntra Sneaker Club among their top three marketing interventions globally and committed exclusive global collections to it. The work was co-presented with Myntra at ESOMAR 2017 and MRSI 2018.

The hard parts

  • Finding the people. Serious collectors were rare in 2017 India. Recruiting them, and earning enough trust for them to open up about something they treated as deeply personal, took persistence. Running the expert conversations remotely helped us reach people we couldn't otherwise have met in time.
  • Speed without shortcuts. We had weeks, not months. We shared findings live and leaned on existing data before going out for primary research, while still refusing to trade rigour for turnaround.
  • Challenging the brief. The business arrived with a clear hypothesis: an exclusive premium store. Our evidence pointed to a community with a wider range. Making that case meant showing, through the construct and the segments, why the consumer's own logic demanded it.

Reflection

This project taught me that the most useful thing research can offer is not a description of a consumer but a way of seeing them. "Nation Within a Nation" gave the team a language for treating sneaker lovers as a culture, and once they could see that, a club made more sense than a store.

Looking back, it also captured a moment. In 2017, finding a collector with a serious collection was a research challenge. Today sneaker culture is mainstream in Indian cities. I'm proud that this work read the culture early enough to help shape it.